Miami Beach

Star Island Homes for Sale & Neighborhood Guide

An iconic oval island between South Beach and the mainland, known for estate-scale parcels and cinematic skyline views.

Reviewed August 2026

CityMiami Beach
SettingBiscayne Bay
HousingSingle-family estates
AccessGated bridge connection

What distinguishes Star Island

Star Island occupies a singular position in Biscayne Bay, reached from the MacArthur Causeway and minutes from both South Beach and Downtown Miami. Its limited ring of homes gives the island a recognizable identity while individual estates vary widely in age, architectural language, frontage, and level of improvement.

Purchases here are rarely interchangeable. Lot width, the shape of the shoreline, outlook toward the skyline or open bay, existing dockage, and the relationship between the main house and grounds can create substantial differences between neighboring properties.

What buyers are choosing

  • Estate properties with substantial bay frontage and skyline outlooks
  • Historic Mediterranean residences beside contemporary compounds
  • Prominent arrival courts, guest accommodation, pools, and docks
  • Fast access to South of Fifth, Downtown Miami, and private aviation routes

What deserves a closer look

  • Historic status, redevelopment potential, and Miami Beach design review
  • Seawall condition, dock permits, and water depth for the intended vessel
  • Privacy from the causeway, neighboring estates, and marine traffic
  • Insurance, elevation, drainage, and resilient-building improvements

Nearby destinations and connections

Travel times vary materially with traffic, bridge openings, events, and the specific property address.

01South of Fifth02Miami Beach Marina03Downtown Miami04Sunset Harbour

See current opportunities in and around Star Island.

Search active listings, then contact John for property-level context, private-showing coordination, and a focused comparison of the strongest options.

Open live property search

Star Island buyer questions

What should I review before making an offer?

Review the property itself, title and survey matters, insurance, disclosures, permits, and the rules and financial condition of every applicable association. The correct diligence plan should be tailored to the residence and the buyer's intended use.

How do I compare current listings accurately?

Start beyond asking price. Compare location within the community or building, exposure, condition, renovation quality, carrying costs, restrictions, and likely capital needs. Recent closed sales then need adjustment for those property-specific differences.

Can John represent international and relocating buyers?

Yes. John works in English, Spanish, Portuguese, and French and can coordinate the real estate process with the buyer's attorneys, tax advisors, lenders, inspectors, and other specialists.

Discuss Star Island with John Stephenson.

Independent market guide. John Stephenson LLC and London Foster LLC are not affiliated with or endorsed by any condominium, homeowners association, developer, hotel, architect, or brand referenced on this page. Building, community, amenity, fee, and policy information can change and must be independently verified. Primary background reference: City of Miami Beach neighborhood resources.